Illuminating Stories of Mental Health Misdiagnosis with Sarah Fay PhD
Original Air Date Wednesday, March 15, 2023
A medical doctor often diagnoses physical ailments through a series of lab tests, x-rays, observations, and data analysis. There are multiple proven guidelines and resources in place for the treatment of disease, fractures, organ failure, and other physical illnesses.
But, for mental health diagnoses, one book, currently in its fifth revision, is the go-to manual for all mental health professionals. To explore how the manual was created, its major flaws, and the consequential misdiagnoses that come from it, Positive Psychology Podcast Host Lisa Cypers Kamen speaks with author and activist Sarah Fay about her investigation and dissection of the Diagnostic & Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM. In her book, Pathological: The True Story of Six Misdiagnoses, Sarah shares the personal mental health journey that led to her writing the book and why she created a public awareness campaign to identify the dangers of the DSM.
Sarah Fay — Mental Health Diagnosis:
- Most of the conditions included in the Diagnostic & Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) are scientifically invalid. [2:05]
- Sarah explains one of the main flaws of the DSM and how 46% of American adults will receive an unproven DSM diagnosis. [8:35]
- Examples of how DSM diagnoses can be racially biased and stigmatizing. [17:26]
- A mental health diagnosis can be a starting point but is in no way a proven truth. [24:17]
- Sarah shares the personal mental health journey that she documents in her book, Pathological: The True Story of Six Misdiagnoses. [29:40]
Sarah Fay PhD is an author and activist. Her writing appears in many publications, including The New York Times, The Atlantic, and Time Magazine among many others. She’s currently on the faculty at Northwestern University and DePaul University and is the founder of Pathological: The Movement, a public awareness campaign devoted to making people aware of the unreliability and invalidity of DSM diagnoses and the dangers of identifying with an unproven mental illness. She holds an M.F.A. in Creative Writing and a PhD in English Literary Studies.
Book: Pathological: The True Story of Six Misdiagnoses
Sarah Fay
@sarahfayauthor on Twitter
Ms Sarah Fay on Facebook
@SarahFayAuthor on Instagram
This podcast episode of Harvesting Happiness Talk Radio about mental health misdiagnosis is sponsored by:
Nutrafol — Tens of millions of Americans experience thinning hair due to hormonal shifts, stress, habits, and aging. Nutrafol goes beyond genetics to target the factors that impact hair growth. It is the #1 dermatologist-recommended hair growth supplement. Take the hair wellness quiz at Nutrafol.com and use promo code Happiness to save $15 off your first month’s subscription. This offer is available to US customers with free shipping on every order.
Are We Happy Yet? Eight Keys to Unlocking a Joyful Life — A boot camp manual for greater emotional fitness. Happiness waits for no one and sometimes we all need support. What is getting in the way of your happiness right now?
H–Factor: Where is Your Heart? — Lisa’s documentary film explores the journey of human happiness. Emotions are contagious and happiness is a universally desired state. We tend to forget we all have the freedom to be happy or the liberty to be miserable each day.
“Is a challenge the same as an illness? Click To Tweet“In my experience, the value of the DSM is to be able to bill for services.” @LisaKamen on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“We don't know enough about these diagnoses that have been essentially invented by groups of psychiatrists and psychologists.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“Everyone who sees a mental health professional should be given an exit strategy.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“The one thing none of these diagnoses take into account is context, and that’s the real problem.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“I really saw how racist DSM diagnosis can be. They aren't always but they can be. They have been found in studies to be biased against children of color, particularly ODD.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“Homosexuality was in the DSM until 1980.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“We’ve ‘psychiatrized’ our language.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“I want a t-shirt that says I Love My Medication.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet“Primary care physicians are actually prescribing 80% of antidepressants.” @SarahFayAuthor on @HHTalkRadio Click To Tweet
CONTINUE YOUR JOURNEY
RELATED EPISODES
On Becoming a Virtuoso of Life
On Becoming a Virtuoso of Life with Kenny Werner Original Air Date Wednesday, February 22, 2023 Many people criticize their abilities. Whether it is taming an instrument or their voice, they judge themselves in lieu of experiencing the joy of the music they aspire to...
Cultivating Dignity and Selfhood for the Deeply Forgetful
Cultivating Dignity and Selfhood for the Deeply Forgetful with Stephen Post PhD Original Air Date Wednesday, February 1, 2023 Age-related memory loss is a natural part of the aging process. Some people experience a more deeply-rooted memory issue, such as...
Lifelong Learning and the Pleasures of Intellectual Development
Lifelong Learning and the Pleasures of Intellectual Development with Zena Hitz PhD Original Air Date Wednesday, January 25, 2023 Socrates is credited with saying, “the unexamined life is not worth living”. Yet, our contemporary world of results-driven work leaves us...